Differences Between Alkaline Electrolysis and PEM electrolysis Techniques for Hydrogen Production

Water electrolysis has been widely adopted in the hydrogen production industry due to its high efficiency and eco-friendly benefits. Generally speaking, there are four main types of water electrolysis methods including ALK, PEM, AEM, and SOEC. As a nickel mesh manufacturer concentrating on supplying quality materials to the green hydrogen production industry, we keep an eye on the trends and developments of all available techniques. In this article, let’s dive into the comparison between the two most popular methods for hydrogen production, ALK, and PEM.

The contrasts between alkaline water electrolysis and PEM water electrolysis present in a number of ways, but mainly in the following aspects:

1 Principle of Operation

Alkaline water electrolysis: Use aqueous solution of potassium hydroxide (KOH) or sodium hydroxide (NaOH) as the electrolyte, under the action of direct current, water molecules are reduced at the cathode to produce hydrogen, and hydroxide ions (OH-) pass through the diaphragm to reach the anode under the action of electric field force, and lose electrons at the anode to generate oxygen and water. The purpose of the diaphragm is to prevent hydrogen and oxygen from mixing, but it cannot completely isolate the two gases from each other.

PEM Electrolysis: Use a proton exchange membrane as the solid electrolyte, replacing the diaphragm and liquid electrolyte in alkaline electrolysis. When the PEM electrolyser is in operation, water molecules lose electrons in an oxidation reaction at the anode side to generate oxygen and hydrogen ions (H⁺), which are conducted across the proton exchange membrane to the cathode under the action of an electric field and gain electrons in a reduction reaction at the cathode side to generate hydrogen gas. The sulfonic acid group inside the proton exchange membrane provides a channel for the transport of hydrogen ions and has a high gas barrier.

PEM water electrolysis system
PEM water electrolysis diagram
alk water electrolysis system
alk water electrolysis diagram

2 Technology Maturity

Alkaline water electrolysis: it is the earliest developed technology of hydrogen production by electrolysis of water, and has already achieved industrial application, with high technological maturity and a more complete industrial chain.

PEM water electrolysis: a relatively late start, but rapid development, has also achieved commercial application, but in terms of technical maturity compared with alkaline electrolysis there is still some room for improvement.

3 Hydrogen Production Efficiency

Alkaline water electrolysis: Energy efficiency is relatively low, usually around 60%.

PEM water electrolysis: Higher efficiency, usually between 70% – 90%, which can make more effective use of electric energy into hydrogen energy.

4 Speed of Response

Alkaline water Electrolysis: Due to the need to maintain equalised pressure on both sides of the cathode and anode of the electrolytic cell, and the nature of the electrolyte determines a slower response rate, with longer start and stop times, usually several minutes.

PEM water electrolysis: It has the advantage of fast start and stop, with cold start time in seconds, which can better adapt to the fluctuating input of renewable energy power generation, and is more compatible with green power.

5 Equipment Cost

Alkaline Water Electrolysis: the equipment cost is relatively low, and the main cost of the alkaline electrolyser accounts for a relatively small proportion of the cost of the hydrogen production system. The cost of its electrode materials and components, such as the diaphragm, is relatively low, and the production process is more mature and easy for mass production.

PEM Water Electrolysis: the cost of equipment is higher, especially the cost of proton exchange membrane and precious metal catalyst, and the cost of the tank body (membrane electrode + bipolar plate + porous transport layer) accounts for a larger proportion of the cost of the hydrogen production system.

alkaline pem cost

6 Gas Purity

Alkaline Water Electrolysis: The hydrogen gas produced may contain a certain amount of alkaline impurities, which need to be de-alkalised, otherwise the purity of the hydrogen gas will be affected.

PEM Water Electrolysis: Pure water can be used directly as raw material, and the hydrogen gas produced is of high purity without additional de-alkali treatment.

7 Maintenance Difficulty

Alkaline Water Electrolysis: Due to the use of alkaline electrolyte, there is a certain degree of corrosion, which requires high sealing and corrosion resistance of the equipment. Maintenance is relatively complicated, and the electrolyte,diaphragm, and other components need to be replaced regularly.

PEM Water electrolysis: The structure is relatively simple and maintenance is less difficult, but the performance of the proton exchange membrane and catalyst will gradually decline as time goes, and need to be regularly inspected and replaced.

8 Application Scenario

Alkaline Water Electrolysis: It’s suitable for large-scale, centralised hydrogen production scenarios, such as large-scale industrial hydrogen production projects or hydrogen charging stations.

PEM Water Electrolysis: It’s more suitable for scenarios that require high hydrogen purity, relatively small scale hydrogen production and fast response, such as distributed energy systems and hydrogen filling stations for fuel cell vehicles.

If you are engaged in the hydrogen production industry and looking for a reliable supplier to get high-purity nickel meshes for hydrogen acquisition or periodical performance testing, please don’t hesitate to contact us. We’re always ready to support your project physically and economically.

Leave A Comment